It’s been a big first week at work. I am teaching a different course this term for the first time since 2003. Yes. That’s right. You heard me. 2003. It’s the academic writing subject that is part of our program. The aim is teach our students to write, research, reference and produce an essay on their own in 12 weeks. We began this week with personal, creative and free writing. We talked about the relationship between language, writing, knowledge, power and learning. We started our daily spelling tests to improve our vocabulary. Most fun of all we started to examine sentence structure with the simple sentence. As one who went to school when we were taught about nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs, phrases, clauses, pronouns etc it is a challenge to translate this into the flashy new functional grammar with its attributes and circumstances. It’s a challenge for the students as well because I think it adds an unnecessary layer of complexity to the understanding of how English works. I can see how it is useful, but I think you have to be schooled in traditional grammar first before you can chuck the functional grammar into the mix. So that is what I attempted to do…in three two hour tutorials. By the end of the week we were all able to find verbs, identify tense, and have some understanding of subject and objects and whether they were nouns or pronouns. We also read a number of interesting readings about the process of writing, and worked on pre-writing strategies (brainstorming and clustering etc). Then on Friday the students wrote a cinquain about winter. For some it was the first time they had ever written a poem and they couldn’t really believe that it might be that easy. So apart from waking at 4am every morning and running through my lesson plan it was a challenging and exciting week of teaching for me. Next week…compound sentences and academic paragraphs, together with some notetaking and paraphrasing from newspaper articles.
5 Comments »
Oooh, exciting!
We stick with the familiar grammatical terms in our writing courses (the linguists probably don't, but we're much more prescriptive than they are), because, let's face it, no one who has been educated in Australia since 1976 has actually been taught grammar, not beyond the basic “nouns are naming words/verbs are doing words” lessons of primary school.
I see no reason to complicate it when my incoming students often can't tell me whether something is a phrase or a clause.
You're exactly right. I was absolutely delighted when a student managed to define both a pronoun and give me a basic definition of a paragraph in the second lesson. None of them had heard of the word “parsing”. Although once I explained what it was there were a few glimmers of recognition from some of the older students.
I feel very fortunate that I had some old-school teachers in primary school up until Year 5 who spent a lot of time on grammar with us. After that though there was nothing. I am no expert but I think it's sad that it has been so removed from the curriculum. It's fascinating stuff!
Well, it's being worked back into the curriculum, which is good. It'll take a while to filter through to us, though.
A long while I would guess. But at least it's a move in a positive direction.
In Grades 5 and 6 we had Let's make English Live with a kookaburra on the front and we learned all those things. I always taught my classes grammar and I think the earlier you start the better it is!! I am very happy they are being grammarised!!!
Happy teaching.